Peer-review in a world with rational scientists: Toward selection of the average

Thurner, S. & Hanel, R. (2011). Peer-review in a world with rational scientists: Toward selection of the average. The European Physical Journal B - Condensed Matter and Complex Systems 84 (4) 707-711. 10.1140/epjb/e2011-20545-7.

Full text not available from this repository.

Abstract

It is widely believed that one of the virtues of peer review is that it provides a self-regulating seection mechanism for scientific work, papers and projects. Peer review as a selection mechanism is hard to evaluate in terms of its efficiency. Serious efforts to understand its strengths and weaknesses have not yet lead to conclusive answers. In theory peer review works if the involved parties (editors and referees) conform to a set of requirements, such as love for high quality science, objectiveness, and absence of biases, nepotism, friend and clique networks, selfishness, etc. If these requirements are violated, what is the effect on the selection of high quaity work? We study this question with a simple agent based model. In particular we are interested in the effects of rational referees, who might not have any incentive to see high quality work other than their own published or promoted. We find that a small fraction of incorrect (selfish or rational) referees is sufficient to drastically lower the quality of the published (accepted) scientific standard. We determine the fraction for which peer review will no longer perform better than pure chance. Decline of quality of accepted scientific work is shown as a function of the fraction of rational and unqualified referees. We show how a simple quality-increasing policy of e.g. a journal can lead to additional loss in overall scientific quality, and how mutual support-networks of authors and referees deteriorate the system.

Item Type:	Article
Research Programs:	Advanced Systems Analysis (ASA)
Bibliographic Reference:	The European Physical Journal B - Condensed Matter and Complex Systems; 84(4):707-711 (December 2011) (Published online 23 November 2011)
Depositing User:	IIASA Import
Date Deposited:	15 Jan 2016 08:45
Last Modified:	27 Aug 2021 17:39
URI:	https://pure.iiasa.ac.at/9494

Actions (login required)

View Item