The co-production of scientific advice and decision making under uncertainty: Lessons from the 2009 L'Aquila earthquake, Italy

Scolobig, A., Mechler, R. ORCID:, Komendantova, N. ORCID:, Liu, W. ORCID:, Schroeter, D., & Patt, A. (2014). The co-production of scientific advice and decision making under uncertainty: Lessons from the 2009 L'Aquila earthquake, Italy. Planet@Risk 2 (2) 71-76.

[thumbnail of 52_Scolobig-52-686-6-PB.pdf]
52_Scolobig-52-686-6-PB.pdf - Published Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.

Download (120kB) | Preview


On 22 October 2012 seven members of the Italian Major Risk Commission were found guilty of 29 persons manslaughter and of 4 injuries in relation with the earthquake that hit L'Aquila, a town in Central Italy, in the year 2009. The members were verdict to six years in prison for violating their obligations to adequately analyse seismic risk and to provide clear, correct and complete information, which might have saved many people's life. The case has not been concluded jet and so far the debate focused on the scientific, legal and communicative aspects of the verdict, while the institutional ones, including the co-production of scientific advice and decision making, received less attention. We argue that the presence of deep epistemic uncertainty coupled with responsibility overlaps of scientists-turned-decision-makers, is fundamental to understanding the event and the legal aftermath. Another relevant institutional aspect is the concern of the national and local authorities that the population would over-react to anything other than a reassuring message. We discuss the consequences of this framing of the emergency management problem in terms of public control rather than public safety. As risk science continues to grapple with the challenge of communicating uncertain information to decision-makers and citizens, it becomes more important to understand the co-production processes that shape how scientific advice is used for decisions on the ground.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Epistemic uncertainty; Science policy co-production; Emergency communication; Communication paradoxes
Research Programs: Risk & Resilience (RISK)
Postdoctoral Scholars (PDS)
Risk, Policy and Vulnerability (RPV)
Bibliographic Reference: GRF Davos Planet@Risk; 2(2):71-76 (April 2014)
Depositing User: IIASA Import
Date Deposited: 15 Jan 2016 08:50
Last Modified: 27 Aug 2021 17:24

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item